Choice

[Derek]

I definitely intend to buy a new Cilt/Kilt during 2006 as soon as finances allow. That will increase my collection to 3 . I was thinking of the Welsh National Tartan then I thought about some other options, which as it turns out, I think I will go along with.
My mothers maiden name was Nelson ... which is associated to the Macneil and Gunn Tartans. Both are nice .. who would choose which one? I like both, but cannot afford two Cilts/Kilts. My intial preference at the moment is for the Macneil.
The first one is Macneil Old & Rare and the second Gunn Ancient
Iechyd Da
Derek

[Valencian Kilted]

McNeill, ...(although Gunn Ancient has also that touch of classic elegance)



Ceaud mille failte! ( I think it was like that!, if not, sorry me! )

¡Saludos!

T O N O

[Graham]

I love the Gunn ancient, very close to my Morrison ancient, lovely greens and blues ohhhh!:-D

[ByDand]

Derek, both look great but I have to agree with Sir Graham, the Gunn is the one. :-D

[Livingston]

Both are great. I like the Mcneil but the Gunn is more subtle. Depends on whether you want it to catch the eye more or less....

[Bob C]

MacNeil. The yellow stripe sets the other colors off nicely.

[chasem]

Being of no relation to either - as far as I know - I think I like the Gunn Ancient better, though I like them both. There are many tartans with a yellow stripe, and I think the Gunn would be an excellent contrast to your bolder welsh tartan cilt. The one with the yellow base anyway, I'm not sure what tartan your second cilt/kilt is.

Anyway, that's my reasoning, it's a little more subdued.

[Ranald]

Just had another thought , get both. Have one now and put the other on order for the future.