Montrose Jacket Question

[crumbaughs]

I have an Argyle jacket for general wear, but was considering getting something more formal. I am not a fan of of the Prince Charlie. I was considering a Sheriffmuir, but the more examples I see of it the less it appeals to me. I am now looking at the Montrose to wear with a jabot, etc on more formal occasions.

HOWEVER, while most of the models I see in advertisements could be said to have a trim, military bearing, I resemble more the fellow who has ignominiously lost the Battle of Shortbread. I am, to be uncharitable, slightly rotund. At 250 pounds (nearly 18 stone) and five feet nine or ten inches, I am underheight.

I put the question to you - will I, in a semi-bell-shaped Montrose Dublet, cut a surprisingly dashing figure for a older chap without a gym membership? Or would I be subjecting myself to ridicule and scorn by those who value their own judgement above kindness towards a quirky yet friendly senior citizen?

[Father Bill]

My opinion only:

I chose a Sherrifmuir for multiple reasons. First of all, for me, the collar shape mimics my clerical collar, a personal preference. The squared off bottom of a Montrose may show a belly gap unless the kilt is correctly worn, and even then it, along with the double row of buttons is likely to emphasize the belly. The Sherrifmuir, on the other hand, is never buttoned up, hanging loose and open with tashes disguising the belly bulge.

Totally, however, your call.

[crumbaughs]

"The Sherrifmuir, on the other hand, is never buttoned up, hanging loose and open with tashes disguising the [battle of the bulge]"
Food for thought here. I like food. Thanks Father Bill!

BTW - looking natty in your Dublet! Thanks for the photo.

[figheadair]

Or a Doublet perhaps? The older style and still the best IMO.

[Panache]

My brutally honest opinion is that the Montrose is most flattering for those gentlemen of a slimmer figure. Also of importance to note is that the Montrose is unforgiving of any gains in the wearer’s weight. The Sherifmuir is a better choice for more full figured gents and allows a little give if their figure becomes …well, fuller.

The Montrose is generally worn with a belt and thus adds another element that can accentuate a gentleman’s waist and attention to it.

I am very glad to own a Sherifmuir doublet as it has worked with my figure even though I have gained a few pounds over the years.

Hope this was of help

Cheers

Jamie

[crumbaughs]

Jamie,
I was hoping for honest opinions.
I didn't find yours very brutal.
It is very useful to me and I thank you for your input.

Steve