Well, I would'nae choose any of these because they are no different with re: historical signifigance, than the Liddell I designed for our family. Liddell is a historically ancient Scottish name, but is not a lowland "clan" nor are we a prominent lowland family, not does we have any historically proven connections as a sept to any recognized clan. Etymologically and DNA, we are seperate and distinct from Little, who do have their own signifigance, and therefor thier own tartan. I designed a Liddell as an homage to my family patronage. The Macinally tartan, although handsome, originated under the same pretense as the Liddell tartan. However, different than Liddell family, Macinally family has a clearly established historic connection to both MacFarlane and Buchanan. Both of which have at least Victorian claims to specific tartans.