
Originally Posted by
David Thorpe
Dalwhinnie 15 is smooth as a baby's bottom. Dalmore 12 is robust but not at all harsh. MacAllan 12 is in the same ballpark and very pleasant. Highland Park 12 has a bit more peat without being overbearing.
David,
Dalwhinnie, Dalmore, and MacAllan are all on my 'ToDo' list. The Highland Park 12 is quite lovely, isn't it? My wife and I both like it. For her, it's as peaty as she will go. For me, it's just the beginning (I'm an Islay kinda guy.) 
Happy New Year! and Slainte!
Allen Sinclair, FSAScot
Eastern Region Vice President
North Carolina Commissioner
Clan Sinclair Association (USA)
Bookmarks