I am now the owner of a clergy tartan semi traditional.
It's the seventh kilt I've bought from Rocky and it fits just as well as the others - perfectly!

My initial reaction to the tartan itself is not really positive. While the tartan matches exactly the swatch on the USAK website, when you see the whole kilt it can look different.
This tartan seems to have a lot of white on it, which I don't like too much, but it's very different to any other kilt I have and I have gotten some good responses already.

I suspect that what is worn with the tartan makes a difference, I may need help from Hamish on this one