If there's a Kohls near you, check these out:

http://www.kohls.com/kohlsStore/PRD~...gtip+Shoes.jsp

I picked up a pair several weeks ago to wear to an event (with the kilt, of course) and they looked good and felt very comfortable. Warning that you might have to get one half size larger as they seem to run small. They have a very nice rounded and not too pointy toe...if that makes any sense...and look more ghilley-like than anything I've seen. Plus...they're currently cheap on sale!

Best

AA