Which outfit is "more Scottish?"

[Bryan]

Please remember, in this case, advice was asked to what A Scot would wear, not what a kilt wearing American would wear.

I find this statement a little condescending. Last I checked, modern-day Scots weren't running around in kilts much anymore (with a few exceptions of course), so the advice given from our Scottish friends on Scottish dress comes mostly from a blue jeans wearing Scots.

Hopefully all went well at Cultural Day for the "kilt wearing American."