Which outfit is "more Scottish?"

[Jock Scot]

Is this a Sherlock Holmes-style hat?

Oh crumbs, this could(will) cause confusion! You will see hats advertised with different labels than the answer I am going to give,so be warned! Where do I start? Traditionally, a deer stalker is the Sherlock Holmes hat and a fore and aft is a bit like a deer stalker but without the flaps. If you stick to those thoughts and ignore anything that says otherwise, it will be less confusing.