It's certainly the Black Watch, though it is very muted for sure. The lighting was low as well, so that added to the muted nature of it I'm guessing, though it *is* the least bold of any of my kilts, all of which are Stillwater Thriftys at this point. The colors and the tartan are correct (I just looked at SWK's website to confirm) but my kilt definitely has less obvious separation and boldness in the colors than the photo on the web shows. Maybe the lighting over-enhanced the colors on the SWK site? Either way, it's a Black Watch. Thanks for the comment!