X Marks the Scot - An on-line community of kilt wearers.
	
	
	
		
		
			| 
	
	
 
		
		
	 
	
		
	
	
		
			
	
		
                        
                                
                                        
                                                17th March 09, 04:34 PM
                                        
                                
                                
                                        
                                                #9
                                        
                                        
                                        
                                
                        
		 
		
		
		
				
				
		
			
				
					Nighthawk, considering how many different (non-celtic) cultures play or played the pipes, why do you say the Celts invented them?  
 In actual fact, they may (as some claim) be north-African in origin, or possibly near-Asian.  There's room to argue for both, more than there really is for Celts.
 
 I personally think the association of pipers with St. Patrick's Day (no matter where he's from originally, he is still the patron saint of Ireland and the first Bishop of Ireland) has to do with the fact that marching uillean pipers just don't look or sound that great.  If you want to have a parade, you need to make it interesting for the audience.  Scottish pipes are closer to being an Irish thing (same general part of the world, after all - and a share in the persecuted feel of living next door to England) than most marching bands.
 
 There are also Irish pipe bands playing GHBs or Irish Warpipes (just a GHB with one tenor drone removed) and that might lead to a certain difficulty in telling the cultural aspect of GHBs apart from Irish life.  Then, you can also find a lot of associations in popular cultural impressions of Ireland. (Scottish pipes show up in Darby O'Gill and the Little People and also in The Quiet Man, which a lot of folks love to watch around today.  I actually own both and love them both.)
 
 Anyway, that's my take on it.
 
 -Patrick
 
	
 
	
	
 
	
	
	
		Similar Threads
			
			
  
    
    
       By Minnow in forum Celtic Musicians
     
    Replies: 27
       
        Last Post: 24th January 09, 01:33 PM
      
  
    
    
       By beatty37 in forum Celtic Musicians
     
    Replies: 23
       
        Last Post: 26th December 08, 06:38 PM
      
  
    
    
       By ChromeScholar in forum Miscellaneous Forum
     
    Replies: 8
       
        Last Post: 16th September 08, 06:56 AM
      
  
    
    
       By Matthew Siegmann in forum Miscellaneous Forum
     
    Replies: 8
       
        Last Post: 4th November 06, 11:26 AM
      
  
    
    
       By Josh_E in forum General Celtic Music Talk
     
    Replies: 11
       
        Last Post: 5th April 06, 06:45 PM
       Tags for this Thread
		
		
		
		
			
				 Posting Permissions
				
	
		You may not post new threadsYou may not post repliesYou may not post attachmentsYou may not edit your posts  Forum Rules |  | 
  
  
  
Bookmarks