very novice...meaning I've done two kilts so far...a tank to stripe and a box pleat.

I just wanted to ask you to elaborate more on your preference in pleating to the stripe? To be sure, I am a fan of pleating to the stripe, as well, with many tartans. However, I don't know that anybody should always claim that this is the style of pleating they prefer, irrespective of tartan. Each tartan is different and some look great pleated to the stripe...others not so much.

In this case, I would advise pleating it to the sett. Why? It's already a two tone fabric...a very simple pattern too. I think pleating it to the stripe makes it excessively busy...almost painful to the eyes.

Just my opinion.