Panache Answers the "Big Kilt Questions"

[xman]

You seriously disagree with the fact that the average person associates kilts with Scotland?? Really?

This is my experience as well. I get asked if I'm Irish nearly as often as Scottish. The kilted Irish are all over the place on St. Paddy's day here so it's likely regional interpretation to some degree and clearly a modern view, not historical.

[madmacs]

This is my experience as well. I get asked if I'm Irish nearly as often as Scottish. The kilted Irish are all over the place on St. Paddy's day here so it's likely regional interpretation to some degree and clearly a modern view, not historical.

My wife and I had dinner out in St Louis Saturday night, and I wore a kilt... The questions I got were:

What clan is it?
Is there a Scottish festival in town?
Do you play the pipes?
Are you from Ireland?

And the comment "you dont see that in St Louis everyday"

Now I will admit that it was a Maclean hunting kilt (green) so that may have coloured the Irish comment, but it does kind if go towards the perception that kilts arent only Scottish

[kc8ufv]

My wife and I had dinner out in St Louis Saturday night, and I wore a kilt... The questions I got were:

What clan is it?
Is there a Scottish festival in town?
Do you play the pipes?
Are you from Ireland?

And the comment "you dont see that in St Louis everyday"

Now I will admit that it was a Maclean hunting kilt (green) so that may have coloured the Irish comment, but it does kind if go towards the perception that kilts arent only Scottish

When people have seen me in my OD UK Original, usually the most common questions I am asked are if I am from Ireland or if I play the pipes. Scottish tends to be way down the list.

[Peter Crowe]

When people have seen me in my OD UK Original, usually the most common questions I am asked are if I am from Ireland or if I play the pipes. Scottish tends to be way down the list.

What you say does happen in North America, but when I speak with my accent (middle class Glaswegian Scots) folk here in the US more often than not ask me if I am Irish, which only proves that many people in the States can't tell the difference between a Scottish and an Irish accent. No one from the United Kingdom or Ireland would ask if my accent was Irish, they might not be able to place it as Central-Western Lowland Scots, but they would be in no doubt I am anything other than a Scot.

Therefore, if people have been exposed to kilts through Irish-American heritage, they might make the assumption that kilts originated in Ireland. In my experience people from Ireland do not make that claim, and all the evidence clearly points to Kilts originating with the Breacon Feile in Scotland from the later XVI century.

[McNulty]

Any ways, Panache, thanks for answering the "Big Kilt Questions". As always, there are after discussion discussions. Either way you go, it was good to read your straight forward answers. I wonder how far/long this thread will go?
McNulty