Help with Tartan ID

[RAF]

Can anyone tell me if these are recognized "official" tartans or merely "fashion" tartans? Just curious. Thoughts?





I'm thinking the red one might be a MacDonald variation? The poor photo quality is distorting the colors a bit. The red in the first picture is more red and less orange. And there's blue AND green in there as well.

[RAF]

Can anyone tell me if these are recognized "official" tartans or merely "fashion" tartans? Just curious. Thoughts?






These are both wool trousers I "inherited."
I'm thinking the red one might be a MacDonald variation? The poor photo quality is distorting the colors a bit. The red in the first picture is more red and less orange. And there's blue AND green in there as well.

MODs please assess the best forum for this post. I'm not sure that it's reached its intended audience as there are no replies.
Thank you.

[Morris at Heathfield]

I believe they're both fashion tartans.

[RAF]

I believe they're both fashion tartans.

This is what I suspected. Thanks for the input!

[RockyR]

The first one looks like a hybrid of the Harvey and Harvie tartans:

http://www.tartanregister.gov.uk/qRe...rchString=harv

The second looks like a weird version of MacMillan Old

http://www.tartanregister.gov.uk/tar....aspx?ref=2656