I really appreciate the side to side comparison between the two tartans!
DECISIONS, DECISIONS !!
I will definitely will need to order swatches in 24" material sizes so I can view each tartan pattern as it would resemble the kilt apron. Hopefully the Great Scot is available in PV... otherwise my choice will be the Spirit of Scotland.

I'm not worried about the extra material because I plan to have a tartan flap sporran & will need to send material to the sporran maker.

(....and you'll never know when another xmts member is in the same situation deciding on this particular tartan)
thank you again for the side to side comparison
shannon