Maybe... Maybe NOT

[MacLowlife]

I have followed the debate over the rogue "Dress Campbell" tartan from time to time, but have never encountered "Black Watch Dress" before:

http://www.ebay.com/itm/SUPERB-16OZ-...item3374b9b9aa

I have to say, it seems to me to be the saddest thing you could do to the BW... It looks like Dress Gordon with the proportions off- way off.

[Droid]

The waist size is mentioned as being a 42" in the bold heading, but then in the smaller font under the picture is says 32" waist. I'd ask the seller before buying it. I had never seen that tartan before.

[Piipriker]

I have followed the debate over the rogue "Dress Campbell" tartan from time to time, but have never encountered "Black Watch Dress" before:

http://www.ebay.com/itm/SUPERB-16OZ-...item3374b9b9aa

I have to say, it seems to me to be the saddest thing you could do to the BW... It looks like Dress Gordon with the proportions off- way off.

look at this: http://www.tartanregister.gov.uk/tar....aspx?ref=4935

[figheadair]

There are at least two other dress variations of Black Watch. It could similarly be sold as Dress Campbell, Sutherland or Hunting Grant.

[TheBrus]

I was married in a Campbell dress tartan kilt. I refer to it as "the wedding tartan", though. If The Campbell won't have it, I'd gladly claim it for my own.

[MacLowlife]

De Gustibus non est disputandem, but I am reminded of Burns:

The best laid plans of mice and men gang aft Ugle'

[English Bloke]

It's not my favourite...

[cruiser348]

Not a big fan of so much white tossed into what is otherwise a very subdued tartan.

[TheBrus]

I had to think back, but I remember someone wearing one in an ancient tone to a Scottish dance evening. His was heavy-weight wool, so the set was a bit larger. In the softer blues and greens, this tartan had a very friendly look to it.