Is it just me?

**Nick the DSM** · 27th April 12, 11:11 AM

I like the actual re-enacting shirts much better, they're historical and they don't have that costume appearance. Same feel, but at least the shirts have historical references.

**kiltedbob** · 27th April 12, 11:18 AM

Ah yes...the debate goes on.... That is why some drive Chev's and some drive Fords...and I drive an 82 VW Rabbit DIESEL!. rattle, rattle, smell, smell, ( great smell)

I think that of the few I have seen, they look good....but then, what do I know... I guess I go with the "if you like it wear it..." at least in the states... Kilted Bob..

**Grizzly** · 27th April 12, 11:25 AM

Originally Posted by Kinetikat

I love 'em, they're just really nice as a casual shirt at the same level as a polo shirt. Don't know why so many people get their regimental tackle in a knot about 'em personally, it's not like they're WHITE HOSE or something!!

Lol Sue. I think they are in the same class as white hose. Now that would be an interesting competition White hose V Ghillie shirt.

**Jock Scot** · 27th April 12, 11:30 AM

Originally Posted by Grizzly

Lol Sue. I think they are in the same class as white hose. Now that would be an interesting competition White hose V Ghillie shirt.

-----------and then there is the "tartan flashes" debate and then the "correct kilt height" debate and of course the "matchy matchy" discussion and not forgetting the "flat c----------------- Oh never mind!

**BCAC** · 27th April 12, 11:37 AM

Yeah, Grizz. I'm with you. I like 'em as well. I have two and wear them regularly. I prefer these shirts to wearing T-shirts with a kilt. (I'll probably be shot down in flames for saying that!)

**Donsel** · 27th April 12, 11:48 AM

To prove diversity and doing/likeing what you want are in, I must admit that I put them in the same drawer as Tilley Hats; never in the life of your dog! Of course, I like white hose and can't understand those who don't.

**eagle43172** · 27th April 12, 11:54 AM

No, don't like 'em.

**dea3369** · 27th April 12, 12:03 PM

I don't have one as I believe they're costumey. Okay to wear if you're in a RenFest or re-enactment or SCA, but "funny" for everyday kilt wear. I don't know, but they remind me of the Seinfeld "Poofy Shirt" episode.

**JohntheBiker** · 27th April 12, 12:14 PM

Can't think of a single place I could wear one without feeling a little foolish. Certainly wouldn't work at anything Scottish in this neck of the woods. Besides, old guys need to preserve a certain amount of dignity!