Quote Originally Posted by Chas View Post
I don't think that an answer to this question can be found. The nearest you will get is a compromise. We are talking about apples and oranges. Whilst they are both fruit, everyone will agree that they are very different.

"snip"
Chas
I agree with Chas, and will echo many of the comments already posted. I own one of each of the two kilts (a USAK trad and B&S casual) and I love them both. Neither are the same as an eight yard traditional wool kilt, but then they don't aspire to be. As Chas says, you will have to compromise. I think you'll be very happy whatever your decision.