As one of the few Craigs on this forum, I am on your side. In your initial posting you mentioned the Gordon tartan. I am aware of the Craig - Gordon association but have never been able to find out exactly what it was. From what you wrote, I assume your waistcoat is a Gordon as you mentioned a similarity to Black Watch and the Craig tartan is much different (see my avatar.) Since you have Gordon in one item why not get a Gordon kilt? They are easy to find and would be less expensive than a made-to-order Craig tartan kilt. The first kilt I ever bought was a Gordon for that very reason. I was not sure how involved I would become in the kilt wearing world. Since that time I have expanded my kilt wearing, limited my tartan wardrobe, and invested more than I ever expected.