Thanks for your comments Hamish, I was wondering where you were, not seen you lately.

You've put your finger on a concern I have about vests...about not wanting to look hysterical, sorry I mean historical

I'm leaning toward a Crail, I like the plain sleeves.
I got a quote from Kiltstore, they were $80 cheaper than buying Scottish jackets from a local importer, even with nearly $70 shipping costs included.

Thanks also Blu, Glen and Miah.