I've seen various videos of modern pipemakers using that same tool to create the bore.
Of course they're using a lathe to spin the wood, but the technique is the same.
About CNC v hand turned, my view is that a bore is a bore, and the wood doesn't care how it was created. The important thing is that the bore is the right ID and length.
Handcrafted bagpipes can sound mediocre or awful, CNC made bagpipes can sound great. What makes a great-sounding set of pipes is having the right specs.
Ditto the visual look of pipes: a handcrafted set can look butt-ugly if turned to ungainly shapes, a CNC turned set can have an elegant classic profile, if such is programmed in.
The influence of the material itself is debated. I know I had two sets by the same maker, one in African Blackwood and one in polypenco/delrin. The bass drones, having identical specs, sounded identical. The tenor drones sounded a bit different, but had different specs.
Yet I also play flute and headjoints made to the same specs by the same maker, but of different woods, have clearly different tone colours and playing characteristics.
Last edited by OC Richard; 10th April 15 at 04:32 AM.
Proud Mountaineer from the Highlands of West Virginia; son of the Revolution and Civil War; first Europeans on the Guyandotte
Bookmarks