Need help regarding jacket lenght

[Benning Boy]

It isn't the ordinary choice but personally I think the best jackets for conversion are those with no vents and patch pockets. With some hunting they can be found on ebay, and if you're fortunate close to home. With such the vent issues are solved and you have flexibility of pocket placement and design.

[Taskr]

I don't think he was asking about a jacket for conversion. He was asking if either jacket would be ok to wear with his kilt.

[Bruce Scott]

Go with the shortest jacket that you have. The photos aren't very clear but the jackets in pictures three and four (possibly the same jacket?) are only sightly longer than the sleeve length. In my view these would work well enough until you can get a kilt jacket.