New sporran

[Tarheel]

I looked on the Buzz Kidder web site and could not get a good look at the sporrans to determine the finish. I expect the gloss of the photo you saw will not be true to the real item. Oils can enrich the sheen and keep the leather supple (as described in the web site) but may stain your kilt if not properly administered and maintained.

Waxes and polishes will "shine" better, but may stiffen up the sporran and make it rigid (with the same concerns of damage to the kilt).

Look at the sporran for what it is first, a carry-all for your personal items. If the one you bought fits that need, and you like the construction-look-feel, get a fancier one for fancier occasions.

Sporrans can also become addictive. My three will easily have company if I don't monitor their social appearances.