Rembering Paschendaele

**Jock Scot** · 31st July 17, 12:21 AM

"Lest We Forget"

**figheadair** · 31st July 17, 02:55 AM

There was a big parade in Crieff yesterday - BBC News

**hector** · 31st July 17, 12:36 PM

The battle at PASSENDALE (not Passchendaele) is one of these dramas which could have been avoided. 500,000 casualties (among which more than 170,000 young men lost their lives) and for what? 8km of mud land which was lost again in no time.
But did mankind learned something from its stupidities?

**Bruce Scott** · 31st July 17, 03:13 PM

Originally Posted by hector

The battle at PASSENDALE (not Passchendaele) is one of these dramas which could have been avoided. 500,000 casualties (among which more than 170,000 young men lost their lives) and for what? 8km of mud land which was lost again in no time.
But did mankind learned something from its stupidities?

Was the village known as Passendale in 1917?

**48HofC** · 31st July 17, 04:05 PM

Originally Posted by hector

The battle at PASSENDALE (not Passchendaele) is one of these dramas which could have been avoided. 500,000 casualties (among which more than 170,000 young men lost their lives) and for what? 8km of mud land which was lost again in no time.
But did mankind learned something from its stupidities?

Please don't use the fallen as a platform to question the leadership of others at times of remembrance, it is just poor form.

**hector** · 31st July 17, 11:49 PM

I do respect the fallen men and women. But history has to be put into its perspective. The reality of the past is also the reality of today. Very sad.