I have a swatch of Dalgliesh's reproduction MacNaughton, as it was the only one in stock similar enough to the Murray of Tullibardine that I was considering. But rather than the scarlet the online images suggested, it was more of a tomato red. Whereas House of Edgar's muted palette is much more to my liking, with a red that's almost burgundy, and blue and green that are darker than they typical ancient colors without being as dark as modern. However, it doesn't seem as if HOE has Fraser Red in the muted colors...but Marton Mills does: http://martonmills.com/product/fraser-red-mtd/

I've never seen any of their wool offerings in what they call muted, but I've made myself a kilt in MacNaughton Muted PV. The green and blue are more like the tan and cool grey of Dalgliesh's Reproduction colors or most weathered palettes. But the red, while not as dark as Edgar's muted, it still a richer shade of scarlet or brick rather than the borderline orange of the Reproduction sample.