Graham,

I agree with Matt's general stance in the article, but I would add a "friendly amendment" to your post, if I may. Another article that appears on Matt's web site has this to say about a person's choice of tartan:

When you wear a particular tartan, you are identifying yourself with whatever that tartan represents.
I think the majority of us on the board who are "traditionalists" agree with Matt's statement that which tartan you wear is a personal choice, but I also strongly agree with Matt's statement above: you are identifying yourself with whatever that tartan represents, so it's best to know the history behind the tartan and not just say, "I like the colours."

For instance, I do presentations on Alexander Mackenzie, the Scot from Stornoway who was the first to reach the Pacific Ocean by land in 1793, some 13 years before Lewis & Clark. I would love to wear a Mackenzie tartan to honour Alex Mac and I certainly feel it would be appropriate to do so, since I am educating people about this Mackenzie's achievements and historic voyage. I could also wear the Muir tartan because of my work as a Park Ranger, since Scotsman John Muir was so active in supporting the National Parks and their efforts to protect our Natural treasures.

So, Jimmy's mantra is once again appropriate: know your tartan!

Cheers,

T.[/b]