Help deciding between a really good 5 yd, 8 yd, and great kilt from USA kilts

[bodhran4me]

To add to what Tobus and others have said, do not just trust in a name or an 'impression' of coming from a reputable maker. I have read threads where a person has had a problem with a 'quality' kilt from a known maker only to find it was improperly constructed with no sewn through stabilizer etc.

Know the questions you want answered and ensure they are answered properly. I have asked if the cloth is UK manufactured and where the kilt was constructed and if it had the proper internal structure. The reply was that they could assure that they were made for the UK market and were quality garments. Not only did they not answer my questions but were somewhat misleading with the whole 'made for the UK market' and I continued to look elsewhere. When asked a pointed question, give a direct answer, do not obfuscate.

Also keep in mind when reading reviews that they are often first impressions and from first time kilters. How does the material and stitching hold up over time? Does it pass the 'stretch test'? Is it hemmed or selvedge? Is it good for the money or is it worth every penny?

Remember also the description 'PV' can covermany different fabrics. The term actually stands for Poly/Viscose but some manufacturers use the term incorrectly to cover acrylics etc. On top of that there are different manufacturers of true PV but the gold standard for kilts seems to be Marton Mills.

Wherever you order from, follow their measuring instructions as there are many different makers and there are many different instructions.

In summary , know what it is buying with your hard earned money.