Ghillie brogues - why the dislike and resentment..?

[Troglodyte]

I can't provide a definitive answer to the OP. Personally, l'm not not a fan and prefer a full brogue.

I am somewhat with you there...

Although they are showing age and use, my old Sanders' army-style full brogue get worn, I guess, 90 per cent of my kilt-wearing time. The distinctive grain and heavy sole sets tham apart from other makes, and they seem tough enough to kick down doors, should the need arise.

But, once in a while, mood or occasion sees me shod a-la-ghillie...