I like the Single post method. It's great to have a central place where we can share good opportunities to get a great deal or awesome service. But we also need to caution each other from our bad experience.

I agree it sucks to have "dog piles" on negatives and rabbit trails with people telling parallel stories and opinions. So if someone wants to share their experience it will be limited to only the review. The reader will determine it's value personally. Any follow up will be restricted to PM's or start a thread in one fo the other forums adhering to the everyday rules.