Derek,

Well, No.3 is so perfectly balanced, but it is essentially a summer look (I'll expect to see that lot on you next summer!). So, really, it's down to No.1 for me, which could be improved with khaki, rather than green, hose - but that's a minor-ish detail!

As John mentioned recently, The Sock Company - Country (in Powys!) has a great selection of what they call "Shooting Stockings" which are perfect for kilt-wear. ( www.sock-co-country.co.uk ) I've several pairs which cost £12.00 pp and khaki features strongly amongst them. Viz: