Ooof, I don't think you can go wrong with either tartan: that being said, I ask if you'll be looking at the Gunn in 16oz or a lighter weight? What weight is your current cilt, 13 oz? The Welsh wool for my cilt is 13oz and soft as a baby's....well, you know. My 16oz kilts on the other hand, are a bit coarser and heavier, but very nice on those brisk spring and fall days. Why not try something a bit different?

Bryan...let us know which you choose...