Thanks for the review Ron. It was very precise.

I think it should be pointed out that you are just comparing specific models from each company though so that some people don't think the companies are being compared on all their offerings.

On one side we have Sporkilts highest offering and on the other we have USA Kilts lowest offering in models. Each firm offers other models to suit their customer's demands and wants.

From a personal perspective, I will always go for the custom made garment rather than off the rack. It's the same with set length in a kilt. If it's not made for me I don't need it, and I will just save the cash.

The MacLean looks great with the green hose by the way.