It's all personal choice of course. But, since my surname is Scottish (Henderson) I went with that tartan for my first kilt, and coincidentally another Henderson tartan for my current kilt on order. There's more Irish than anything else on my mother's side. But, I did find some Gilmore/Morrison in there, and I will most certainly have a kilt made in the "Morrison Red" (ancient) tartan. SO, I guess my answer to you is: GET BOTH!