Funny how opinions differ. I was always taught that the loops were for the sporran not the belt and for my liking I think it works the best on a traditional kilt that way. I like the fact that the loops help keep the sporran in place. I can still move it if I like but I don't need to reposition repeatedly. Since the belt is purely decorative I am glad to remove it easily. If I am driving much of a distance I will usually remove the belt and put it back on when I arrive. Of course I don't wear a belt at all if I am wearing a waistcoat so frequently I am not worried about the belt at all.