Yes. In my case, modern hunting Barclay from House of Edgar looks different than modern hunting Barclay from Strathmore. Different mills will ge their wool thread from different places and use different dyes. So the blue from one, might not look like blue from another. What you could do is send Matt the scarf and let him choose. The sash is probably featherweight material, not suitable for kilts. If no one else produces it, he could have woven for you.