Hot Stuff!

[berserkbishop]

As for whether plastic kilts (and let's not kid ourselves, for that's what oil-derived fibres basically are) are 'real' is, I accept, a matter of opinion. If your idea of a kilt is defined by its shape, then indeed anything goes. But if your definition, like mine, encompasses ideas of tradition and authenticity, then there is surely a hierarchy of quality.

Don't get me wrong. I have a collection of kilts of my own that include denim, leather, and one-off overprinted kilt2 specials that no one else on earth has. But these are fashion garments, in natural materials (that just don't burn remotely as easily!) which extend the kilt's heritage in exciting new directions, rather than mocking it. As such they are part of the evolving tradition. Artificial wools to me are very different -- a second-rate copy of the original, designed to deceive; they add little of merit to the tradition but only ape the real thing, and badly in my opinion.


Artificial fibres are a necessary compromise for anyone allergic to wool (which is why Scotweb / KiltStore sells expertly made polyviscose ones ourselves). But otherwise I can only see them as second best. That's my own aesthetic judgement.

This is where my feathers became ruffled, and I probably posted my previous thought without giving it enough consideration; so Nick, let me clarify what I mean. I DO NOT think that you should start another account. You have a right to an opinion as much as I do, but sometimes biting comments, whether intentional or not, can cut deep for unseen reasons. Now without going into a sob story I am going to tell you what threw me into a little tizzy. I was a foster kid, and through the events that led to that status, I really didnt have much contact with extended blood family. I always knew I was somewhat Scottish but that fact didnt come to life until recently as I have been struggling to build strong personal relationships with this extended family. I have done research and learned a lot and I really feel proud to have Scottissh blood running through my veins. The first time I put on a kilt in the MacLeod tartan the feeling was indescribable. When I read what you wrote about my kilt-o-synthetic fibers apeing the tradition it cut deep. As I stated, I am having a tank custom made for me, but I still feel the pride when I wear my SWK. It is the best I could do with the money I had at the time. I dont wear it to destroy the tradition of a wool kilt, I wear it because it is an affordable way to show my pride in my heritage. I never said that it was authentic and when people inquire about my kilt I am more than happy to explain what an "authentic" kilt is and why they are great. I dont necessarily disagree that PV or acrylic is secondary, but right now it is my primary and I will wear it with pride. Oh, and to put your mind at ease I was just spouting off about not ordering. . . you have some great deals and a well put together website. Again I apologize if my first post was to biting. I appreciate your support of this forum. My order for 8 meters of double with 16 oz Cunningham will be in soon!