I don't have a Celtic Croft kilt, but I do have two USA kilts and just got my fiancee one of thier kilted skirts for Christmas. I have a casual model and a semi-trad. They're both great, and I wear them all the time, The casual was the first kilt I got from them, and its great. The Quality is outstanding, the quatlitly is outstanding on all three kilts as a matter of fact. However in retrospect I wish I would have forked over the extra cash for the semi-trad. The semi-trads are great, they are a giant step up from the casual model. When you strap it on, it looksand feels much more like a "real" kilt, and the price is quiet reasonable.

I have one FG kilt, in the Clark tartan, it was my first acrylic kilt, I will never ever buy another acrylic kilt, I absolutely hate the way it feels on, I think Ive worn it twice. Its just not for me.. The PV kilts however , are much much much nicer than acrylic. Theyre light and strong, the look and feel nice, the swish is outstanding, and in my opinion they are far more presentable. You could wear a USA kilt semi-trad anywhere, formal or casual.