How is this shirt?

[Splash_4]

I might be prejudiced here, but in the south there are times that you wear an undershirt under EVERYTHING including other tshirts trying to stay dry.

From my vantage point, shirt works well with the tartan and you should not worry about it...

[Abax]

I wear polos with the kilt all the time. I don't know about the undersleeve showing, though.

I suspect that is the design of the shirt.

The shirt and kilt look fine to me. I say for casual, if you like it, wear it.

Abax

[gseven1]

Personally I think it looks great. No worries from what I can see.

[McMurdo]

I think it looks fine the main colour being the blue ties in nicely with the Leatherneck Tartan and you wear it well.

[Nick the DSM]

O-M-G! that is just terrible! a disgrace to the kilt! you should stick to jeans, its so terrible!

nah, man, it looks fine.

[vmac3205]

I like seeing a polo shirt with a kilt, and the color looks good from here. As for the undershirt hanging below the sleeves.....it looks like your slip is showing. The white around the neck looks just fine. I just have a problem with the white hanging down.

[Ranald]

Well I can see nothing wrong with that, looks good to me.
What flashes if any have you decided to go with?

[Birddog]

The undershirt is part of the polo; just extra sleeves and neck line. Thanks for the comments.

[Nervous Jock]

looks fine chief

[macwilkin]

The shirt looks good to me. The blue and the white are solid colors. Solid colors work best with a tartan kilt. Striped shirts are too busy to wear with a tartan kilt.

I can't say I agree with that. Bob Martin discusses "toning" patterned shirts with tartan in his book All About Your Kilt.

Matt Newsome, for example, has a picture of himself wearing a window-paine shirt from L.L. Bean with his Carolina tartan kilt, and it looks very "country-gent".

So don't automatically discount patterns -- stripes may be a bit much, of course.

T.