Quote Originally Posted by McClef View Post
There is a fine line between reviews and individual endorsements and what might be construed as unpaid advertising. Ron's enthusiasm for Kathy's work is well-known as is the enthusiasm of other members for other kilt makers.

But it does need to be in proportion - remember it's the sponsors who pay that enable this site to exist. Publicising a PM that generates this amount and level of discussion could be construed as free publicity and giving an unfair advantage especially when she isn't even a member. That's her right and choice of course and she is unlikely to know the rules or be responsible for the enthusiasm of her patrons.

"Concerning personal forum member Advertisements on X Marks the Scot

Statement of Intent-

X Marks the Scot prides itself on the diversity of the skilled craftsmen and artists who make up the membership of our forum. These individuals contribute much in the wealth of experience they freely share with the forum. We hold these individuals in high esteem. Our valued forum sponsors pay to advertise their businesses here and by so doing allow this forum to exist. We hold in equally high regard those that have invested in us and it is our desire to see that this investment is one worthy of their commitment.

Therefore it is the intent of the owner and moderating staff of X Marks the Scot to present guidelines that allow for the creativity and entrepreneurial spirit of the forum members as well as protect the interests of our sponsors.

Those individuals interested in advertising with X Marks the Scot are encouraged to contact any of the moderating staff by personal message (PM) and current advertising rates will be provided.

Those craftsmen and artists wishing to include a link to their wares and services are welcome to do so.

Individuals attempting to bypass the intent of these guidelines for the purpose of using X Marks the Scot for advertising without permission or payment will be subject to user infraction, restriction, or being banned as deemed appropriate by the moderating staff."

Just trying to ask for balance and keeping within the spirit of the rules.
I would be surprised if Kathy Lare has ever asked to have her name used in this or any other forum. I don't believe that there is any intention on Kathy's part to "bypass the intent of these guidelines."

Like Ron, I sing the praise of Kathy's skill and work, and will continue to do so. Her prices are reasonable and her craftsmanship exceptional.