Not sure if all the suppliers you mentioned are middlemen or not. For sure USA Kilts is a kiltmaker. I've had the best success dealing directly with kiltmakers. Have a saffron semi-trad from USA Kilts, a beautiful and well made kilt.

Its nice to be able to talk direct to your kiltmaker - either face-to-face or on the phone. Have yet to read of an unhappy kiltie who did business with Rocky and Kelly. Having purchased 23 kilts from them to date I consider myself qualified to comment on their quality and service.