Wow so many great replies and all between midnight and 9 am.
I just got off the phone with Robert MacDonald. He's obviously very enthusiastic about kilts and that comes through. I'm going to email him for a quote. Right now I'm leaning about 50% in his direction.
Looking at freedom kilts I'm not sure it's for me. They make "contemporary" kilts. I think I want something traditional tho. It seems like http://www.freedomkilts.com/model.php?val=tartan would be the one to get if any. The focus on pockets is not interesting to me. A kilt already has a giant pocket hanging in the front.
Looking at Burnett & Struth the prices are similar to Roberts':
http://www.burnetts-struth.com/index...th=109_130_135
Heavy Weight Edinburgh Kilt $603.00
Balmoral Heavy Weight Kilt $699.00
Which is right for me?
All the other kilts at B&S are called "casual" which I assume is not appropriate for a wedding.
If I'm going to spend that kind of money I think I'd rather go to Robert.

Alright I'm off to House of Maclaren to see what they say. I'll report back when I've made a decision.