Member Rankings/Titles

[Tobus]

vBulletin has a built-in 'reputation system'. This allows users to, anonymously, rate the quality of other member's posts. If this debate is only about ranking quality, then this is a possible solution.

I was an admin on a forum that had that. It gets abused real quick and becomes more of a distraction than anything else. It became a way for members to "war" with one another in a passive-aggressive manner. It did nothing but drag the whole forum down.