For what it's worth, I have a FB in black leather and muskrat. The black leather is supple, very high quality and is not 'plasticy', stiff and fake-looking like some leather finishes can appear. I am EXTREMELY pleased with my purchase and would recommend a FB sporran to anyone. Black leather as a surround to a lighter fur would be stunning. If black leather is what your husband usually wears, go for it. However, either brown or black will be a home run - FB sporrans are incredible!