Kilt pin location

[Spartan Tartan]

Thanks all! I appreciate the feedback.

[OC Richard]

My favourite place for a kilt pin is in a drawer somewhere!

Sooner or later a kilt pin seems to get caught on something and tear the kilt a bit. Look at a pile of 20-year-old band kilts from a band that wears kilt pins and you won't see many that aren't torn.

Anyhow in this matter as in so many others what the Army does is what looks "right" to my eye:



I like a pin more or less halfway between the bottom of the kilt and the edge of the jacket. They always look odd to me when pinned at the very bottom edge of the kilt.

[Standard]

I usually have the bottom edge of my kilt pin at about 6" up from the bottom edge of the kilt, and about 2" to 3" in from the apron edge. As Rivekilt said I tend to place my kilt pin, especially sword shaped, or horse-blanket pin styles in a manner that to my eye looks good on the section of the sett where they lay. To me wearing it too high doesn't seem to feel right, but I know Robert does this with great success.

[Montgomery-the-Scot]

So. . . .the kilt pin doesn't hold the apron together? Or did I understand that one statement wrong?

[davidlpope]

So. . . .the kilt pin doesn't hold the apron together? Or did I understand that one statement wrong?

No. The kilt pin only goes through the outer apron. It's meant as a decoration.

David

[OC Richard]

What's perhaps interesting is that early military kilts didn't have buckles, and were held at the waist by pins.

The only regiment that wore kilt pins was the Gordon Highlanders, and they wore blanket-pin style pins (as you can see in the photo I posted).

Which makes me wonder if the Gordon Highlanders kilt pins evolved from the pins originally holding the kilt on, simply a matter of one of the pins migrating further down the kilt a bit, where it's visible, and where it became decorative.

I don't believe the story that Queen Victoria ordered all the kilted regiments to wear kilt pins when she saw the wind blowing a soldier's kilt up. For one thing, only the Gordons wore them. For another thing, if the wind blows up that edge of the upper apron the lower apron is underneath. If the wind blows hard enough to lift both aprons, it's going to do so whether or not a kilt pin is there, the military blanket pins having insignificant weight when pinned to a heavy 22oz military kilt. (I know from personal experience, having worn MOD kilts and 16oz civilian kilts in all sorts of wind both with and without kilt pins.)

[creagdhubh]

What's perhaps interesting is that early military kilts didn't have buckles, and were held at the waist by pins.

The only regiment that wore kilt pins was the Gordon Highlanders, and they wore blanket-pin style pins (as you can see in the photo I posted).

Which makes me wonder if the Gordon Highlanders kilt pins evolved from the pins originally holding the kilt on, simply a matter of one of the pins migrating further down the kilt a bit, where it's visible, and where it became decorative.

I don't believe the story that Queen Victoria ordered all the kilted regiments to wear kilt pins when she saw the wind blowing a soldier's kilt up. For one thing, only the Gordons wore them. For another thing, if the wind blows up that edge of the upper apron the lower apron is underneath. If the wind blows hard enough to lift both aprons, it's going to do so whether or not a kilt pin is there, the military blanket pins having insignificant weight when pinned to a heavy 22oz military kilt. (I know from personal experience, having worn MOD kilts and 16oz civilian kilts in all sorts of wind both with and without kilt pins.)

Well said Richard.