-
21st January 09, 01:53 PM
#1
TH, this is awesome stuff! I'm curious on something, the the standing temp in the 8 yard kilt appears to be climbing right up to the point you begin walking. I wonder how high it would go if you did not start walking.
The temp increase in the 4 yd kilt appears to flatten out just after 5 minutes and the Polly/cotton kilt climbs at a very slow and steady rate.
Just curious if you get a chance to stand around outside in the sub-zero temps if you wouldn't mind measuring how warm the 8 yd kilt will go while standing.
-
-
21st January 09, 08:47 PM
#2
 Originally Posted by cavscout
TH, this is awesome stuff! I'm curious on something, the the standing temp in the 8 yard kilt appears to be climbing right up to the point you begin walking. I wonder how high it would go if you did not start walking.
The temp increase in the 4 yd kilt appears to flatten out just after 5 minutes and the Polly/cotton kilt climbs at a very slow and steady rate.
Just curious if you get a chance to stand around outside in the sub-zero temps if you wouldn't mind measuring how warm the 8 yd kilt will go while standing. 
Yep, I noticed that, too. I don't think it compromises the data since I let all three adjust to the outside temp for the same length of time, but it would be neat to see how high it would go. It's 16 degrees outside right now....
Kilted Teacher and Wilderness Ranger and proud member of Clan Donald, USA
Happy patron of Jack of the Wood Celtic Pub and Highland Brewery in beautiful, walkable, and very kilt-friendly Asheville, NC.
New home of Sierra Nevada AND New Belgium breweries!
-
-
22nd January 09, 05:38 PM
#3
This is indeed a real and significant contribution to the art and science of kilt-wearing. Well-done sir. It is well-designed within its own restrictions. The fact that it supports apparent anecdotal wisdom is part of its contribution to the body of knowledge of kilt-wearing.
The results of this most recent research will arm the ordinary and not-so ordinary kiltwearer with information that can calm and inform the curious minds of non-kilt wearers when in the winter they ask - "Are you not cold in that?" or "Isn't too warm to wear that?" in the summer (the answer to the second question will be explored in the proposed follow-up research). And also to inform the wearer and assist him or her in decision-making for a future or current purchase - which kilt design; what length, etc.
May I add a couple of suggestions?
- Perhaps you can perform the same experiment indoors to simulate temperatures that are closer to ambient room temperatures as a first approximation to a more summer-like weather? In lieu of waiting for the summer. Or with external funding, perhaps fly to the southern hemisphere to conduct research there? Additionally, performing indoors has the added benefit of eliminating or reducing the less controllable meteorological variables.
- I would also like to suggest extending the walking data acquisition with an extra 5 minutes (or longer) to allow for a minimum of 10-minute temperature equilibration period.
- Attach a temperature probe to the selvedge of the kilt on the inside of the inside apron - to approximate the temperature near the knees. Attaching to the apron section will perhaps eliminate or reduce the "swish" factor on the edges of the kilt.
- There are more variables that can be thought of which can increase the complexity of follow-up research; realizing what the current materials and equipment is able to support. The point is that this is just one more variable that I believe may be relevant to the wearer.
What is the science method but the the ability to reproduce the results, so I also recommend a duplicate or triplicate experiment. It will only strengthen the paper.
Overall, a very fine study. Thank you for sharing your results with us.
Last edited by meinfs; 22nd January 09 at 06:51 PM.
Reason: additional point.
-
-
22nd January 09, 06:35 PM
#4
GREAT RESEARCH>
The "swish factor was of special interest to me. One of the things, I have observed, wondered about (in my un-scientific observations) is that my "regimental issued" (18-20oz) kilts are warmer when walking than my WPG 22oz kilt ( sim. style) IMHO, the reason is that the "regimental issue" is more fitted in the hips & therefor fits closer to my thighs.& do not "open up as much at the bottom. ??????
Puffer
-
-
21st January 09, 02:18 PM
#5
What a wonderful subject for serious research! Your study was very well thought out and nicely presented. Thanks!
The fear o' hell's the hangman's whip To laud the wretch in order; But where ye feel your honor grip, Let that aye be your border. - Robert Burns
-
-
21st January 09, 02:27 PM
#6
Whew. At first I thought TartanHiker had an arrow through his head. If so, all the heat escaping would have skewed the data.
Jim Killman
Writer, Philosopher, Teacher of English and Math, Soldier of Fortune, Bon Vivant, Heart Transplant Recipient, Knight of St. Andrew (among other knighthoods)
Freedom is not free, but the US Marine Corps will pay most of your share.
-
-
21st January 09, 02:34 PM
#7

You, sir, are my hero.
That. Was. Awesome. I love science.
Thank you for your nerdiness and dedication to the kilt!
-
-
21st January 09, 03:41 PM
#8
Pursuant to other current threads - I'm not really sure that cowboy hat goes with that kilt... 
Seriously, a fine bit of well documented research!
-
-
21st January 09, 04:15 PM
#9
Entertaining, interesting and informative.
-
-
21st January 09, 05:37 PM
#10
Tartanhiker, you had me at
measure of molecular motion
, we may have to open a new category now.... what else can we test.... labcoat kilt hmmmm!
-
Similar Threads
-
By ChromeScholar in forum General Kilt Talk
Replies: 5
Last Post: 6th January 08, 03:42 PM
-
By souzaphone711 in forum General Kilt Talk
Replies: 30
Last Post: 23rd March 07, 11:47 AM
-
By freddie in forum Kilt Advice
Replies: 3
Last Post: 1st April 06, 10:14 PM
-
By toadinakilt in forum General Kilt Talk
Replies: 2
Last Post: 30th July 05, 05:07 PM
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|
|
Bookmarks