I have a few kilts from Heritage of Scotland and I think they are a great value for the money. I also have a couple of heavyweight kilts from Stillwater and they are nicer still. I also have a tank from Scotland that cost much more, but is absolutely fantastic. True kilties will notice the quality differences between a HoS, a Stillwater, and tank, but most of the public won't. I wouldn't be heart broken if one of my kids took a magic marker to one of them, which would happen if they did that to my tank!

You get what you pay for, but everyones budgets are different and it matters more that you enjoy and are happy wearing kilts than the label on the kilt.