Quote Originally Posted by ThistleDown View Post
Is there a reason for deviating? The sgian of today may be used by those of us who wear the kilt as a pocket-knife is by those who wear trousers, but not as some sort of weapon.
***

The sgian dubh is a component of traditional Highland attire. One's choice should therefore be made with respect for tradition as a primary consideration. Otherwise, just stick your weapon of choice in your sock and call it whatever you like.