They're all lovely! You have a good eye for nice tartans, to choose a lineup like that.

I voted Black Watch Weathered because I've seen that tartan worn from time to time and it always looks so beautiful, so classy, so timeless.

Auld Lang Syne is lovely too. I've not seen that tartan in that colour scheme before; it's the nicest version IMHO.

My reservations about Douglas is due to it being one of the most popular Kilt Hire tartans in Scotland for a few years now, and I've seen it far too often for it to strike me any other way than ordinary. Sad that the beauty of a tartan can be sapped due to mere surfeit, but there it is.