A Cautionary Tale if Your Pipes Have Ivory

[creagdhubh]

Ridiculous indeed. I heard about this through my good mate and professional piper, Matt Pantaleoni. He's just over in Scotland right now competing in the solo-piping circuit and heard the news there. Let's just say he's furious! And rightly so. He has been urging his fellow pipers and pipe enthusiasts here in America to write to their respected Congressman and Senators, as well as sign the various petitions that have been circulating.

"If you are a piper or piping enthusiast -- whether you own ivory pipes or not -- I urge you to write to your Congressman and Senators and make them aware of the new executive order's devastating impact on musicians generally and particularly pipers. We must make our voice heard! Musicians are not criminals!"

-Professional Piper and Piping Instructor Matt Pantaleoni, August 5, 2014

http://www.king5.com/news/local/Ivor...262753251.html

http://www.forbes.com/sites/dougband...-as-criminals/

[Ron Abbott]

A politically correct world gone mad.

Is this sort of thing happening just in North America or elsewhere as well?

I've certainly travelled to/from the UK on a number of occasions with silver and ivory mounted pipes and the only time I've ever been stopped was going through security at Edinburgh Airport when the security guard, a former soldier; asked whether my drones were .303 or 7.62mm.

Once he laughed at his own joke, he let me through without any further issue.

[MacRobert's Reply]

Hopefully good sense will prevail and the pipes will not share the fate of the old sealskin sporrans that Scottish wedding guests had confiscated by US customs ... and never returned.

[creagdhubh]

The pipes have been returned, after a hefty fine was paid, of course.

[Aussie_Don]

<dons Nomex suit >
There is another side to this -- elephants are getting way
too close to extinction. And the reason is ivory.

Don't misunderstand me, I'm fully aware that the pipes under
discussion were from a time when the extinction was not an
issue. But I believe that there is a real need to make sure that
anything that includes ivory is clearly certified as not being
"modern ivory". And this is not PC gone mad or anything of the
sort. There are a lot of ivory poachers out there who'd like
nothing more than to manage to get their ivory certified as being
from "before".

I personally have a good deal of sympathy with the pipers in the
original story. The real problem is setting up a system that will
protect living elephants without making things impossible for
those who own historic ivory items. It sounds like they may
have got it wrong this time. But if you think that it is important
that your children/grandchildren should have the chance to see
an elephant in the wild, then you need to consider the importance
of this protection.

-Don

[tky58]

With respect to our brother's across the "pond", Americans have a long history (238 years) of disliking high handed government interference.

This system that caught these teenage boys is fraught with bureaucratic idiocy. The professional ivory smuggler is not going to deal with teenagers as mules. He is going to bury 50 pounds of the stuff in a shipping container of something else and run it through a busy seaport. He is going to take his time and have all his papers in order so as not to raise suspicion. Most of the time, customs will not bother with something so complicated.

However 2 kids who told customs they had the items before they went into Canada and declared them upon return. That is just easy picking for the bored customs agent who would rather be catching all those illegal Canadians slipping into the US in search of a better life. (I pull my tongue out of my cheek and not go further in fear of becoming political)

Truth is I appreciate our border agents and believe they are trying to do a good job in a tough situation. Bureaucratic idiocy is systemic and given a choice most bureaucrats will want to do the right thing.

[Theyoungkiltman]

The answer: paint over the ivory.

[Theyoungkiltman]

Imho the problem is that all the foreign gov. burn or otherwise destroy ivory captured from poachers when it could be sold to reduce demand. Some african nations have special permission to do that now. This will not entirely end poaching but along with tighter enforcement of poaching laws (not possession of small quantities) and increasing stability of nations that contain elephants poaching will be greatly reduced.

[tulloch]

The pipes have been returned, after a hefty fine was paid, of course.

What is the whole story? Why a fine if he had the certificates? How much was the fine?

[unixken]

The pipes have been returned, after a hefty fine was paid, of course.

So what's to stop the same thing from happening again, I wonder? Upon paying the fines, were they given documentation that exempts the pipes from future seizures? Or are they still at risk of repeat, every time they travel?