I concur with the others about going with a clan tartan.
While I’m a fan of ancient colors for blue/green tartans, for red/green tartans, I prefer the muted or modern colors as the red in ancient palette is very orange-y and the green is fairly bright.
My first kilt (Maxwell tartan — red/green/black) — was in the ancient colors. I later acquired Maxwell kilts in modern, hunting and muted colors. I find that my ancient kilt is worn the least by far.
I really like the hues of the House of Edgar muted tartans, but only wish they were available in 16 oz. instead of 13 oz.
Here’s a photo of the kilts to show the differences in the colors. (Top to bottom: ancient, modern, muted and hunting)

Looking forward to seeing what you end up with!
Cheers,
SM
Last edited by ShaunMaxwell; 8th June 20 at 10:22 AM.
Shaun Maxwell
Vice President & Texas Commissioner
Clan Maxwell Society
Bookmarks