Yeah, I was really torn on whether to get the 5-yard knife or the 4-yard box. The idea of a box pleat never sat well with me until I saw the pictures on his website. His work looks amazing. I think that in the end the main reason I went with knife-pleats was because it's my clan tartan and I just wanted a kilt that looked more like a "traditional" kilt. I know, box pleats pre-date and all that... but most non-kilters think of a kilt with knife pleats when someone mentions one... That said, I'll probably end up with a box pleat from Matt at some point... you know, when debt gets paid and I get a raise... some where down the road...